On August 5th, a wave of panic swept through the Tokyo Stock Exchange, marking a dramatic and historic event often referred to as "Black Monday." The Nikkei index plummeted by an alarming 4,451.28 points, concluding the day at 31,458.42 points—a staggering drop that surpassed the previous record decline set in 1987. This drastic turn of events was fueled by a collective investor panic, triggering massive sell-offs and resulting in futures trading halts on both the Osaka and Tokyo exchangesThe dismal performance of the U.S. economy compounded concerns, sending shockwaves through global markets as countries like South Korea, Germany, Malaysia, Vietnam, and Australia experienced varying degrees of declines in their stock indices.

Analysts point to a combination of disappointing U.S. economic data and the Bank of Japan’s recent interest rate hike as the primary culprits behind this turmoilOn July 31st, during a monetary policy meeting, the Japanese central bank simultaneously raised rates and reduced government bond purchases, increasing the policy interest rate from a range of 0% to 0.1% up to around 0.25% while slashing monthly government bond purchases from 6 trillion yen to 3 trillion yenCoincidentally, the U.SFederal Reserve concluded its own policy meeting that same day, hinting at a potential interest rate cut in SeptemberAmidst this backdrop, it became clear that American economic indicators were significantly underperforming expectationsThe U.SInstitute for Supply Management reported that the ISM manufacturing index fell to 46.8 in July, moving even further from the critical threshold of 50. In a further blow, the U.SLabor Department revealed a substantial miss in the number of new jobs added in July, along with a rise in unemployment rates to 4.3%, the highest since October 2021. Additionally, the Commerce Department reported a concerning 3.3% decline in new orders for manufactured goods in June, which collectively catalyzed a downward spiral for New York’s major stock indices.

As investors anticipated a narrowing gap between U.S. and Japanese interest rates, there was a notable trend towards buying yen and selling dollars, causing the yen exchange rate to surge by more than 4% at one point, reaching levels around 141 yen to one dollar

Advertisements

With Japan’s economy heavily reliant on international trade, fears about an impending U.S. recession heightened uncertainty in the global economic landscapeThe yen’s appreciation further exerted pressure on Japan’s export-dependent companies, leading to an atmosphere of panic among investors eager to escape the uncertain market conditions.

Within Japan’s academic circles, there is a belief that the panic surrounding this stock market drop is reminiscent of, but distinctly different from, the crises seen during Black Monday in 1987 and the Lehman Brothers collapse in 2008. While the intensity of market fluctuations in American and European futures has not reached catastrophic levels, it can be argued that the so-called “Japanese panic” has acted as a trigger for volatility in the global marketsThe increase in Japan's policy interest rate further limits the Bank of Japan’s ability to maneuver and pivot in response to the crisisGovernor Kazuo Ueda's comments hint at potential further rate hikes within the year, indicating that anxiety in the financial markets could continue to escalate and that uncertainty looms over the future of Japanese equities.

Following the Nikkei’s record decline, Japan’s Finance Minister Shunichi Suzuki addressed the media, emphasizing that the government would collaborate with the Bank of Japan to closely monitor both domestic and international economic developmentsHowever, he refrained from providing a definitive reason for the stock market downturn, instead stating that economic conditions and corporate trends were ultimately determined by investors’ judgments and market forcesHe urged investors to maintain a cool-headed perspective, recognizing the importance of long-term, diversified investmentsPrime Minister Fumio Kishida echoed these sentiments on August 6th, stressing the need for calm assessment of the situation while promising ongoing cooperation with the Bank of Japan to enhance economic stability.

While the immediate spark was ignited in Japan, the underlying issues originate from the United States

Advertisements

Observing the stock market data on the morning of August 6th reveals that the economic landscape in the U.S. heavily influences both Japanese and global stock valuesAfter enduring a record-setting fall the previous day, the Nikkei index rebounded by more than 3,400 points in the early hours of August 6thThe swift rise in stock buybacks caused Osaka’s exchange to once again initiate trading halts due to the volatilityThis "rollercoaster" effect has primarily stemmed from shifting expectations regarding the American economyData released on August 5th revealed that the October reading of the ISM Non-Manufacturing Index came in at 51.4, better than the anticipated 51, with the service sector employment index showing its first expansion since January and marking the largest growth since September of the prior yearWith indicators of business activity and new orders returning to an expansionary phase, investor confidence received a much-needed boost, alleviating worries over the global economic outlook and reversing expectations for premature or aggressive interest rate cuts by the Federal Reserve.

By the afternoon of August 5th, the exchange rate of the yen against the dollar fell back to about 145 yen to the dollarAdditionally, a report from Japan’s Ministry of Health, Labor, and Welfare released before trading on August 6th indicated that real wages in Japan had experienced a year-on-year increase of 1.1% in June, marking the first uptick in 27 months—this timely data served as an additional catalyst for driving up Japan's stock market.

However, some experts argue that the U.S. continues to serve as the epicenter of stock market turbulence globally, including within JapanDespite Japan’s larger declines, the U.S. stock market has exhibited less severe drops, which may reflect a trend of "over-panic" among Japanese investors or may signal ongoing volatility within U.S. marketsRising concerns over a potential recession in the U.S. could lead to persistent crises in both Japanese and global stock markets

Advertisements

Advertisements

Advertisements